Polarized Light Weirdness

  Polarized Light Weirdness

Polarized CrystalsThe same weirdness problem arises when we pass light through polarized devices as in the figure at the left.  The devices are calcite crystals in which the light is split into two parts, a horizontal (H) and a vertical (V) channel.  If we try to send individual photons through, they go through only one channel or the other, never through both, and those that come out of the H channel are always horizontally polarized, those that come out of the V channel are always vertically polarized as we might expect.  

It is possible to orient photons to other angles at the input.  One such arrangement is to adjust them polarized so that they are tilted 45 degrees right or left as illustrated in the same figure.   If we orient the input to 45 degrees, tilted right, we get half of the photons coming out the H channel and half out of the V channel, one at a time, but these are always horizontal and vertical polarized, no longer polarized at 45 degrees right.  

Reversed Crystal setupNow comes the weird part.  See the figure at the left.  If we put a second calcite crystal in line with the first one, but reversed so that the H channel output of the first goes into the H channel of the second and the V channel output of the first goes into the V channel of the second, we expect the output to consist of one photon at a time (and it is), but since the first crystal only outputs horizontal or vertical polarized photons we expect only horizontal or vertical polarized photons out of the second crystal.  

 Quantum Weirdness at work.

However, if we test the polarization of the output, we find that the photons coming out are oriented to 45 degrees right, exactly like the input.  Individual photons go in at 45 degrees right at the input, are still individual photons but horizontal or vertical oriented in the middle, but come out oriented 45 degrees right again at the output!  Somehow the two channels combine as if the individual photons go through both channels at the same time, despite rigorous testing that detects only one at a time.  Quantum Weirdness at work. 

The polarization problem, like the double slit problem, is often called a quantum measurement problem.  An often-quoted theory is that the photon does go both ways, but any attempt to detect/measure one of the paths disturbs the photon such that the measurement results in a change in the path of the photon.

My theory reafferms the idea that it does go both ways, but in a manner you would not expect.  We will get to that later.  Next I want to mention  Quantum Weirdness in Glass

Advertisements

2 responses to “Polarized Light Weirdness

  1. I love the experiment!
    Any thoughts on what to expect if we introduced a significant delay in one of the channels. Where we “could” tell which channel a short burst traveled by the time delay ?

  2. You would need to read the post describing my theory (part 3) above the banner https://quantumweird.wordpress.com/quantum-weirdness-a-matter-of-relativity-part-3/
    to undersand fully my answer, but these are individual photons, not bursts. However, in truth, bursts are made up of individual photons too. It is my thought that the photon spans the experiment and all paths because it experiences no time during its flight, even within the prism. So it recombines around the paths if it can, and doesn’t if it is blocked or the delay is intolorable to it. The delay doesn’t disclose anything because the complete path (all the delays) is available to the photon when it enters the experiment and the photon will recombine if the path (and delay) is conducive to recombination and won’t if not. It will not recombine if it can’t get the full energy packet to meld at the far end.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s